Home
>
Guide
>
L'oreal Hair Color vs. Garnier vs. Clairol: Which Brand Is Best for You?

It contains affiliate links and Extrabux will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on Extrabux links.

L'oreal Hair Color vs. Garnier vs. Clairol: Which Brand Is Best for You?

Today's at-home permanent hair colors are easy to use and offer a quick and inexpensive way to update your look without the cost and hassle of a trip to the salon. The L'oreal Hair Color, Garnier, Clairol are the most popular hair dye brand from editor's favorites, and consumer picks on best-selling hair dye. But which one is best for you? Today I will write a L'oreal vs. Garnier vs. Clairol Hair Color guide for those who want to add some subtle highlights or touch up those pesky grays for $10 or less, to help you to find the best one!

Cover Photo: valuavitaly on freepik.com

Performance and Effectiveness

1. L'Oreal Excellence Creme Permanent Hair Color review

No hair color cares more than EXCELLENCE® Créme Permanent Triple Protection Hair Color: With triple protection system that seals, replenishes, and conditions, plus 100 percent gray coverage even on stubborn grays, it's called Excellence for a reason. L'Oreal Paris Hair Color comes in multiple formulations and styles to deliver long-lasting color, from fade-defying Superior Preference, to bold, stylish Feria, and gray-coverage from Excellence Crème.

Source:target.com

Hair Type: All Hair Types (Gentle to fragile, fine, dry, permanent waved and chemically relaxed hair)

Product Form: Cream

Health Facts: Aluminum-Free, Paraben-Free, Sulfate-Free

Product Warning: Not recommended for those with sensitive skin

Processing Time: 25 minutes

Highlights：

-100 percent gray coverage, even on stubborn grays.

-Triple protection system protects before, during and after coloring for up to eight weeks.

-Pre-color treatment protects and primes hair.

-Rich, radiant, gorgeous hair color from root to tip with exclusive non-drip creme formula.

Where to Buy Cheapest:

$9.79 + 0.5-1% Extrabux cashback @cvs.com

$7.99 + 5-6% Extrabux cashback @walgreens.com

$7.99 + 4.5-6% Extrabux cashback @riteaid.com

$8.99 @lorealparisusa.com

If you like online shopping, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux！(What is Extrabux) , then you can enjoy up to 30% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus!

Ps. Difference between L'oreal Excellence and Preference creme：

L'oreal Preference and Excellence both are permanent hair colors.

Excellence provides 100% gray coverage with triple protection that seals, replenishes and conditions your hair.
Preference is a gorgeous fade defying color with incredible dimension and luminosity.

2. Garnier Nutrisse Color Cream review

Inspired by nature: Garnier carries an array of products for your hair and skin care needs, from shampoos, color care and styling products to formulas that cleanse, moisturize and repair skin. It's the only hair color creme with a separate ampoule of grape seed oil to start nourishing as you color. Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Permanent Hair Color Creme nourishes while you color with avocado, olive, and shea oils.

The nourishing color creme enriched with fruit oil concentrate, penetrates deep into hair fibers to nourish and condition your hair so it takes color better and holds it longer, root-to-tip. Garnier Nutrisse delivers rich, radiant, long-lasting hair color with 100% gray coverage. It's easy to use - complete nourishing, hair color kit.

Source:target.com

Hair Type: All Hair Types

Product Form: Cream

Health Facts: Aluminum-Free, Paraben-Free

Product Warning: Not recommended for those with sensitive skin

Processing Time: 25 minutes

Highlights:

-Permanent, nourishing hair color creme with three fruit oils- avocado, olive, and shea.

-The only hair color creme with a separate ampoule of grape seed oil to start nourishing as you color.

-Rich, radiant, long-lasting color with 100 percent gray coverage.

-Available in 45 Nourishing Shades.

Where to Buy Cheapest::

$6.99 + 0.5-1% Extrabux cashback @target.com

$6.97 + $0.8-$1 cashback @instacart

$6.99 + 5-6% Extrabux cashback @walgreens.com

From $5.99 + 4% Extrabux cashback @bedbathandbeyond.com

3. Clairol Nice'n Easy Permanent Hair Color review

Clairol Nice N Easy Permanent Hair Color blends 3 tones into every shade - The breakthrough Color Care permanent crème has conditioners built into every step, to make your hair soft and shiny. It gives you 100 percent gray coverage with real natural looking tones and highlights while being kind to your hair. It helps you keep gray hair at bay by providing real, natural looking luminous color. With clairol nicen easy permanent coloring creme you get the color that cares for your hair.

Formulated with the revolutionary ME+ hair dye molecule, Clairol Nice'N Easy delivers outstanding permanent color performance while reducing the chance of developing allergy. The special formula is kind on your hair without compromising on color results.

Source:target.com

Hair Type: All Hair Types

Product Form: Cream

Health Facts:

Product Warning: Adult Use Only

Processing Time: 25 minutes

Lasts Up To: Up to 8 Weeks

Highlights:

-Permanent color crème for brilliant, natural-looking color with a blend of tones and highlights.

-Allergy gentle - significantly reduces the chance of developing an allergy* (*in people without hair dye allergy)

-Non-drip formula with conditioners built into every step for soft, shiny hair.

-Blends 3 tones into every shade.

-New fresh, floral scent.

Awards: 2018 Seal of Approval, Good Housekeeping Magazine.

Where to Buy Cheapest::

$6.99 + 4.5-6% Extrabux cashback @riteaid.com

From $5.59 + 4% Extrabux cashback @bedbathandbeyond.com

$6.99 + 0.5-1% Extrabux cashback @target.com/

$6.92 @walmart.com

Conclusion

1. L'Oreal Excellence Hair color

L'Oreal Excellence Creme Permanent Hair color is enriched with special polymers, the conditioning agents are especially gentle to fragile, fine, dry, permanent waved and chemically relaxed hair.

Make hair easy to detangle, manageable and silky to the touch. L'Oreal Excellence Creme Permanent Haircolor has a unique foaming action that makes application a breeze.

It's easy to mix and use. It gives great coverage and results with rich tones plus the additional benefit of conditioning.

L'Oreal Excellence Creme Permanent Haircolor has a unique foaming action that makes application a breeze.

2. Garnier Nutrisse Color Cream

Garnier Nutrisse delivers enriched with fruit oil, penetrates deep into hair fibers to nourish and condition your hair so it takes color better, root to tip.

The Garnier Nutrisse Hair Color Line is really great for people who have been dying their hair for years, as well as beginners.

Each box comes with clear directions and even plastic gloves. Their website has a bunch of tutorial videos teaching and demonstrating different dyeing techniques. They even have a “Shade Selector” on their website which helps their customers find the perfect shade for their hair needs.

Nutrisse Ultra Color is formulated with intensity-enhancing color boost technology, and a blend of triple fruit oils-avocado, olive, and shea--to deliver bold, boosted permanent hair color that nourishes while you color.

3. Clairol Permanent Hair Color

If you want to enhance the color of your hair and make sure that it stays perfectly true to you, Clairol Nice'n Easy permanent color crème gives you the nicest and easiest way to refresh your look from the comfort of your home.

Choosing between three beauty brands doesn't have to be difficult. Especially if you're choosing a haircare brand.

First of all, most of the products in this category are cheap.

Secondly, many people often find the course to go back and leave a review on a product. So you'll find reviews on a particular product, which will help you make an informed buying decision.

Thirdly, when buying though, you should consider your budget and your skin/hair type. If you have permed hair, for instance, you'll definitely want to choose a color-safe product. Else, you may find that the product doesn't work for you.

If you have sensitive skin, you have to look over the ingredient lists carefully. Some ingredients are very okay for sensitive skin while others may not be as good.

Source:freepik.com Racool_studio

L'oreal Excellence Creme Hair Color vs. Garnier Nutrisse Color Cream vs. Clairol Permanent Hair Color: Which one Is Best for You? How Can I Choose?

Garnier is a branch of the L'Oreal cosmetics company, but a significant difference exists in the price and quantity of the product. Garnier and L'Oreal differ in appearance, but some products are similar in composition.
They have different qualities and factors - Garnier products are easy to use, and for L'Oreal, you will need the instruction manual; Garnier is very cheap and L'Oreal is more expensive.

So, L'Oreal Excellence hair color is a little more expensive, but a lot of women are happy to buy it because of its existence from Garnier's hair color.

Garnier is good for regular use, and L'Oreal is used for special purposes; Garnier hair colors have the highest overlap strength and flush the least.
As for Clairol Nice n Easy you might know that it also has a PH level closer to 7 than any other hair color on the market. This means that technically it is the least damaging of any hair color you can buy. And Clairol hair color is cheap too.

The problem with Clairol Nice n Easy is the after-color conditioner that they give you is not very good. This could be why you think it`s damaging your hair. If you follow it with a good quality salon conditioner, that should be fine.

Both L`Oreal and Clairol make excellent colors. But L`Oreal color lasts a little longer, give you hair a bit more shine and their conditioners are a little better. Keep in mind their colors cost more than Clairols do.

Important Tips for Safety:

Haircolor and bleaches contain ingredients which may cause allergic and/or other types of reactions. A skin allergy test is required 48 hours before each use of a haircolor product.
Bleaches contain persulfates. Bleaches and high-lift haircolor shades cannot be used on relaxed hair.
For other haircolor shades, wait at least 14 days after bleaching, relaxing or perming before coloring.

If you want to get one, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux.com, then you can enjoy up to 6% cashback from Extrabux!