It contains affiliate links and Extrabux will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on Extrabux links.


BRUNT vs. Red Wing vs. Thorogood vs. Irish Setter: Which Brand Wins the Work Boots Showdown?

BRUNT vs. Red Wing vs. Thorogood vs. Irish Setter: Which Brand Wins the Work Boots Showdown?

    • Over the years, the best work boots on the market deliver unmatched performance and comfort to workers in various industries, with a range of features designed to meet the demands of different job sites, environmental and work conditions. And with so many work boot brands on the market, it can be easy to overlook the towering icons of the industry. Some such icons just like BRUNT,Red Wing, Thorogood and Irish Setter, which get compared frequently. So Which brand is best for work boots? Is BRUNT a legit company? What boots are comparable to Thorogood or Red Wing? Are Irish Setter boots comfortable? Are BRUNT worth it? Or are Irish setters as good as red wings? If you’re wondering which brand is the best, this article will tell you everything you need to know before picking one over the other for your next pair of boots or shoes.

Cover Photo:图片来源 作者, 补充说明

  • BRUNT Work Boots Review

BRUNT Brand History and Origin

BRUNT Workwear is a consumer brand that provides work boots and clothes. Its product catalog includes abrasion-resistant boots, apparel, socks, insoles, hats, and gear that are made of moisture-wicking materials. The company was founded in 2020 and is based in North Reading, Massachusetts.

BRUNT Boots are aimed at those who practice trades such as construction and any other field that demands comfortable yet functional work boots.

Moreover, their boots are designed to protect the feet as hard work takes a toll on the body over time. Their prices are also typically more affordable than other big-name boot brands due to their direct-to-consumer business approach.


BRUNT Work Boots Prices

 BRUNT boots range from $139 to $179, considerably cheaper than most top-rated boot brands (and definitely cheaper than most popular work boots out there).

BRUNT Work Boots Design & Style

BRUNT Workwear truly offers something for everyone, from composite toe boots like The DiStasio, The Perkins and The Ryng, to soft toe boots like The Marin (arguably its most famous offering) and The Kasparian. Regardless of your preferences, you should be able to find boots that not only fit you, but also provide exactly what you need for your particular job tasks, worksites and shift lengths. 

Just in case your boots don’t fit exactly the way you originally envisioned, each offering has adjustable widths. By simply removing the gray insert that’s located below each boot’s insole, you can effortlessly alter your boot’s size from a regular fit (D) to a relaxed fit (EE). 

Aside from their adjustable widths, BRUNT work boots have several design features that ensure you’ll remain comfortable for hours on end. 


BRUNT Work Boots Quality & Material 

Some boots have cement constructions that guarantee comfort and flexibility right after you’ve taken them out of the box. Others have mesh linings that enable them to maintain their breathability, even during hot summer days.  

Not to mention, some also have soft bottom layers, middle layers comprised of memory foam and lightweight designs, which allow you to take thousands of steps a day—without the negative effects that are typically associated with heavier boots. 

In addition, BRUNT work boots have various features that will increase your safety on the job. First, they have soles with built-in oil and slip resistance, allowing users to work on wet, uneven terrain. And they’re electrical hazard rated, thereby providing you peace of mind as you work in hazardous environments. As a result of these key safety features, the boots meet ASTM F2892-18 standards as well. 

Of equal importance, BRUNT work boots feature triple-layer waterproofing, ensuring they’ll remain protected from heavy rain and snowfall. In turn, your feet will remain dry for hours on end, despite Mother Nature’s unpredictability. 


BRUNT Work Boots Pros and Cons

  • Affordable price

  • Leather color looks good

  • Multiple toe options available 

  • Insole is very soft

  • No break in

  • Fully waterproof

  • ASTM F2892-18-compliant sole

  • Lack of arch support.

  • Online sales model means you can’t try them on before purchasing

Where to Buy BRUNT Work Boots Cheapest? 5% Super Cash Back

Tips: is the only place selling them right now; they're not even on Amazon.

Two Popular BRUNT Work Boots

1.Brunt Marin Boot  (@$139)


Everyone from project managers to electricians loves the versatility and comfort of the Marin.  Combining a classic time-honored look and high-quality durable construction, this boot is designed to keep you protected from the rigors of any environment.  

2. Brunt Ryng Boot (@$139)


Lightweight.  Durable.  Heavy-duty tread for unparalleled traction.  The Ryng Boot is designed for movement, so you can enjoy all-day comfort and protection in any environment without feeling weighed down.  

Money Saving Tip:

If you like online shopping, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux!(What is Extrabux) , then you can enjoy up to 30+% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus! Student Benefits:As long as you are a student at school, you can get a free whole year long VIP Card worth $199 cooperates with many merchants, such as: Walmart (Up to 4% cashback), Sephora4% -5% cash back),Dior (Up to 6% cash back), Moosejaw (5% -6% cash back), LOOKFANTASTIC (Up to 10% cash back), Microsoft (Up to 7% cash back) and so on.

  • Red Wing Work Boots Review

Red Wing Brand History and Origin

Red Wing Shoes (Red Wing Shoe Company, LLC) is an American footwear company based in Red Wing, Minnesota that was founded by Charles H. Beckman in 1905.Within 10 years of its inception, Red Wing Shoes was producing more than 200,000 pairs of boots per year and was the primary company manufacturing footwear for American soldiers fighting in World War I. Red Wing Shoes continued its tradition of producing footwear for wartime use by manufacturing boots for American soldiers during World War II.

Though Red Wing Shoes is known primarily for their leather boots intended for heavy work,in recent years the company has expanded its line-up to include athletic-styled, work shoes and footwear designed for specific job applications such as slip-resistant shoes designed for the service industry and boots for the mining industry that utilize a metatarsal guard.

The company produces Oxfords, chukkas, hiking boots, and logger styles, as well as 6-inch and 8-8 1/2 inch work boots.[citation needed] While the core of Red Wing's focus is on work boots, in 2008 Red Wing Shoes added a Heritage catalog and also has experimented with more fashion-oriented shoes.


Red Wing Work Boots Prices

 A lot of Red Wing Work Boots price ranges from $215 to $350, but they also come with many more features in comparison and offer extra protection.

Red Wing Work Boots Design & Style

Known for their reliable work boots, Red Wing’s main focus is for added protection on the job site rather than everyday wardrobe staples.Still, you can find many different designs, each of which comes with a construction quality that helps defend your feet against harsh working conditions.

Their boots are made to take a beating, stocked with various protective features such as waterproofing, protection from electrical hazards, steel toe, and more.

Red Wing Work Boots offer the ideal blend of safety, durability, and comfort, ensuring you can focus on your job without worrying about your feet. Whether you work in construction, manufacturing, agriculture, or any other industry, they have the perfect work footwear solution for you. 


Red Wing Work Boots Quality & Material 

Red Wing is also widely known for the quality of its products. Although they may have many stylish designs, they are well-known for their craftsmanship and for creating durable boots that last for years (and in some cases, decades).

Tried and tested on industrial work sites for over a century, Red Wing knows how to make a great pair of construction boots. With premium material and cutting-edge safety technology, every model of footwear can last for years without losing performance or comfort.

Providing boots with technologies such as BOA fit systems, GORE-TEX, Thinsulate, and Vibram, Red Wing work boots are modern footwear for the construction workers of today.


Red Wing Work Boots Pros and Cons

  • Interesting leather options that age and patina beautifully

  • Durable and can hang with work, riding, or just as a style boot

  • All Red Wing’s leather options are durable, easy to care for, and age wonderfully.

  • The lacing system isn’t made as good as it could be. 

  • Very little shock absorption

  • The Red Wing boots are a little heavier than normal work boots, but that’s to be expected given the industry. 

Where to Buy Red Wing Work Boots Cheapest?


  2. up to 11.5% cashback

Two Popular Red Wing Work Boots 

1.Red Wing King Toe 8-Inch Waterproof CSA Safety Toe (@$279.99)  


Red Wing’s King Toe 3512 has it all: it’s EH-rated, puncture-resistant, has a non-metallic safety toe, and features a waterproof design. If you happen to be north of the border, it’s also CSA-approved. It can handle the heat, too, with an HRO sole that’s rated at 475°.

2.Red Wing Classic 6-Inch Moc-Toe (@$329.99)


The classic moc-toe has gained a lot of popularity over the years in part because of the Goodyear construction and also, the contrasting sole with Traction Tred. This boot was created using Red Wing’s No. 23 last. This was developed in the 1950s and is arguably one of the most popular last styles.

  • Thorogood Work Boots Review

Thorogood Brand History and Origin

Thorogood Shoes is a Weinbrenner Shoe Company that’s employee owned and has been assembling footwear in Wisconsin since 1892. Thorogood’s parent company, Weinbrenner was formed in 1900, 8 years after Albert H. Weinbrenner — the company’s founder — opened a cobblery in Milwaukee as a 27 year old. It wasn’t until 1918 that the Thorogood line of boots was born.

By 1927, Weinbrenner became a major contributor of boots to the U.S. Army in World War I. And 9 years later in 1938 they began crafting safety footwear.In 1942 the company celebrated its 50th anniversary and produced all-military footwear for the duration of WWII, which included combat and dress styles.

At this time the military style boots became popular with civilians. And by 1964 the Official Boy Scout Boot; The Hike ‘n Camp which features a wedged sole and moccasin style stitching was released and became the company’s best-selling boot of all-time.


Thorogood Work Boots Prices

Thorogood work boots typically range in price from $150 to $299

Thorogood Work Boots Design & Style

Thorogood work boots prioritize comfort and performance, designing them to stand up under tough conditions. Providing a wide range of exceptional, heavy-duty, and lightweight footwear, they offer options to keep you safe and productive on any construction site. Boot options include waterproof and insulated materials and steel toe, composite, and metatarsal protection options.

Focusing relentlessly on craftsmanship and innovation, Thorogood recognizes the importance of having the highest possible quality of work boots. That's why their footwear is extensively tested and certified to make sure it meets or exceeds to highest possible ratings given by the American Society for Testing and Materials.

Easily some of the most used work boots among contractors, Thorogood work boots offer high performance and excellent comfort to anybody who chooses to use them.


Thorogood Work Boots Quality & Material 

And then on the inside of the boot, you’ll find a removable Poron comfort cushion insole for added comfortability. It also helps to give you a better fit if the boots are slightly large on your feet. But the brand moved to their own custom MAXWear slip resistant sole for durability reasons. While the Vibram Christy performs a little better in oily conditions, the MAXWear sole resists abrasion much better. 

Furthermore, these Thorogoods are laced with Taslon laces. These are strong, heavy duty and long lasting shoe laces. You can just feel that they’re made to last when you lace up your Thorogood boots for the first time.

And then on the inside of the boot, you’ll find a removable Poron comfort cushion insole for added comfortability. It also helps to give you a better fit if the boots are slightly large on your feet.


Thorogood Work Boots Pros and Cons

  • Inexpensive

  • Lightweight

  • Low maintenance leather

  • Durable, grippy sole

  • An actual workboot that can be worn to a bar

  • Leather aged quickly, but it’s fine for the price

  • Kind of gaudy branding

  • Not that formal

  • Sole may be a bit hard for certain consumers

Where to Buy Thorogood Work Boots Cheapest?

  1. tractorsupply.com3% Super Cash Back


Two Popular Thorogood Work Boots 

1.Thorogood Moc Toe Non-Safety Wedge Work Boots (@$249.99 )


The Thorogood moc toes are rugged style work boots similar to Wolverine or Red Wing. They feature 3 standard eyelets followed by 3 speed hooks and finished off with a single grommet. The speed hooks aid in easy lacing and makes heel lock lacing a breeze. 

2.Thorogood Men's Gen Flex 6" Lace-to-Toe Composite Work Boot (@190)


Sale price$190)

Slip-resistant, lightweight, and comfortable, these boots are made with the GEN-Flex2 outsole for reliable traction and support. Brown oiled, full-grain leather is combined with a durable cap toe for long-lasting wear, while inside, you’re protected by the non-metallic composite safety toe that doesn’t conduct electricity. 

  • Irish Setter Work Boots Review

Irish Setter Brand History and Origin

Irish Setter is owned by Red Wing Shoe Company. In fact, the current flagship and world famous 877 heritage boots were once Irish Setters.

In 1950, Red Wing introduced a 9-inch lace up sportsman boot for hunters, style 854, in the Oro-Russet color which is similar to today’s Oro-Legacy. That Oro-Russet color was the inspiration behind the name Irish Setter because, well, it looks like the color of the fur on an Irish Setter dog.

As you may have guessed it, that 9-in 854 style boot was essentially today’s 877 with a heel. The flat-soled 877 was born in 1952 and replaced the 854 as the company’s most popular boot. 

As time went on, the Irish Setter boots developed into their own brand and became a world famous hunting boot brand. In 2003, Irish Setter introduced the WingShooter, a hunting boot, and found it became popular at job sites across the country. So in 2017 they decided to make a version of that boot that could truly meet the safety needs of tradesmen across the country.


Irish Setter Work Boots Prices

Irish Setter work boots cost between $159.99 - $249.99. Sales and coupons for purchasing multiple pairs of shoes can bring these costs down lower.

Irish Setter Work Boots Design & Style

In 1950, the first of many boots known simply as “Irish Setter” were designed specifically for hunting, and featured the distinctive Oro-Russet leather, the same color as an Irish Setter hunting dog.

By the 1970’s, workers are wearing Irish Setter boots every day on the job as well as out in the field. New materials are introduced including highly waterproof kangaroo hide with a Vibram® sole and double-layered leather. 

In the 1990’s, the Irish Setter hunting boot line was expanded to 14 styles. In 2000, Irish Setter celebrated its 50th anniversary with a unique logo. Style #882 became a flagship big game hunting boot for tough backcountry terrain.

Today, Irish Setter boots continue to deliver on this heritage of excellent, confidently leading hunters and workers into any terrain – in all weather conditions and back out again.


Irish Setter Work Boots Quality & Material 

Irish Setter employ the following key technologies to make Irish Setter boots as tough as the conditions they are worn in:

Strategically placed high-rebound material brings high-end athletic shoe technology to more practical applications, delivering a recharging burst of energy with every step.

UltraDry construction combines a moisture management lining with waterproof components for dry, long-lasting comfort and performance.

THERMALBOOST is a revolutionary, multi-zone barrier system that delivers serious insulating protection against brutal cold and biting wind. ThermalBoost is strategically built into specific areas of the boot, such as the toe box, beneath the insole and within the footbed, where heat loss is most common.

CuShin Comfort tongue technology was designed to minimize pressure some feel on their shin from the top of the boot tongue. A four-way stretch nylon offers relief and flexibility while walking, and an internal padded waffle mesh maintains premium comfort.


Irish Setter Work Boots Pros and Cons

  • True-to-size fit

  • Lightweight for a work boot

  • ASTM compliant safety toe, slip resistance, and electrical shock resistance

  • Totally waterproof 

  • No break in period

  • Good shock absorption and comfort

  • Able to be resoled

  • Available in wide widths

  • Cement construction forefoot isn’t as strong as direct attach boots in the same price range

  • Not great arch support

  • Wedge sole not ideal for logging

Where to Buy Irish Setter Work Boots Cheapest?


  2. dickssportinggoods.com2% Super Cash Back

Two Popular Irish Setter Work Boots 

1.Irish Setter Crosby Work Boots (@$219.99 - $229.99)


The Crosby leather work boot is specifically designed for people who need flexibility in the front of the foot for bending, twisting, and crawling and stability in the heel that offers rugged durability.

2. Irish Setter Wingshooter ST   (@$219.99 - $249.99)


The Wingshooter ST is one of people favorite work boots and when you wear them, you'll see why. They took the original Wingshooter hunting boot and upgraded it to meet all the requirements of a versitile, durable, and comfortable work boot. The non-metalic safety toe keeps your feet protected and the comfortable sole is a long lasting, heat resistant material that keeps you safe and secure in any environment. 

  • Conclusion: Which's the Best Work Boots Brand for You?


Overall,BRUNT boots are comfortable and lightweight, but aren’t meant to take on super heavy-duty work. They can be a great option for those who are on their feet all day or need a pair of shoes that they can rough up and replace every now and then.

If you’re looking for a quality boot that won’t fall apart, will keep you warm and dry, is breathable and light, is grippy, has great design, and will fit both slim and wide feet, then this work boot is for you.

They also allow returns on most products within 30 days with no questions asked, so you can get a feel for their boots risk-free.

Red Wing 

Red Wing Shoes is known primarily for their leather boots intended for heavy work and the Iron Ranger and Classic Moc Toe are excellent boots.

Red Wings have more room in the toes, but that also makes them much bulkier. If you want a heavy, chunky, outdoorsy, old world workboot, Red Wing is for you.

Red Wing can tailore its shoes to the demands of specific customer groups, offering a wide range of shoe sizes and widths to ensure fit, and a constantly growing line of specialized products with different capabilities. 


Thorogood is often the brand highlighted for comfortable work boots. While contractors debate whether comfort starts with the weight of the shoe, insoles, or linings, Thorogood has it all. 

With great shock absorption, lightweight design, removable insoles, and padded collars, these Thorogood  boots will feel comfortable on your feet for long hours.

If you need a custom insert for Plantar Fasciitis, flat feet, or just extra arch support and want a lighter boot for comfort or a more budget friendly option, Then get the Thorogood Moc Toe.

Irish Setter

Irish Setter boots are built for hard work - from the construction site to the farm or factory floor.

For example, Irish Setter Crosby works boots find a nice middle ground as an all-rounder kind of boot. You can find more stable boots if you’re on soft or unpredictable ground all day or more cushioned boots if you’re on concrete all day.

They also sit in the pricing middle ground between inexpensive boots that lack comfort and durability and premium boots that can cost more than $250. Even the style is versatile enough for just about anyone.

Read More:

Rossi vs. Blundstone vs. Redback vs. Beckett Simonon: Who Wins the Boots Brand Showdown?

Sorel vs. Kamik vs. Baffin vs. BOGS: Which Brand Wins the Winter Boots Showdown?

Thursday Boots vs. Red Wing vs. Beckett Simonon vs. Tecovas: Who Wins the Boots Brand Showdown?

Dr. Martens vs. Blundstone vs. Redback vs. Thursday Boots: Which Brand is the Best?

Sperry vs. L.L.Bean vs. Sorel vs. Hunter: Which Brand Wins the Duck Boots Showdown?

R.M.Williams vs. Blundstone vs. Allen Edmonds vs. Red Wing: Which Brand is the Best? (Quality, Design & Price)

Timberland vs. Dr. Martens vs. Red Wing vs. Solovair: Which Brand is the Best? (History, Quality, Design)

Orthofeet vs. Vionic vs. OOFOS vs. Birkenstock: Who Makes the Most Comfortable Shoes for Plantar Fasciitis?

Sorel Caribou vs. 1964 vs. Carnival vs. Joan of Arctic: Differences and Reviews 2024

UGG Mini vs. Ultra Mini vs. Mini II: Differences and Reviews 2024

UGG Tazz vs. Tasman vs. Coquette vs. Ultra Mini: Differences and Reviews 2024

Veja vs. Cariuma vs. Superga vs. Allbirds: Which Brand is the Best? (History, Quality, Price & Design)

2024-01-30 19:49594