It contains affiliate links and Extrabux will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on Extrabux links.

9

Cooler Battle: Yeti vs. Igloo vs. Coleman vs. Lifetime?

Cooler Battle: Yeti vs. Igloo vs. Coleman vs. Lifetime?

    As the weather warms up, a dependable cooler is an essential tool for backyard get-togethers, camping trips and tailgating.When you’re in the market looking for a budget-friendly cooler it’s very common to be torn among Yeti, Igloo,Coleman and Lifetime.They’ve successfully disrupted the market and changed the way that consumers view coolers with aggressive marketing and extremely high-quality products.Cooler from four brands share lots of features, but they also differ in a number of ways.What cooler is better than a Yeti?Is Lifetime as good as Yeti? Is Igloo better than Yeti? Is Igloo better than Coleman?Is Coleman a good brand for cooler?Are Lifetime coolers worth it?Yeti vs. Igloo vs. Coleman vs. Lifetime:what's the difference?Which is best cooler brand?I will be comparing the differences between these coolers in this article. You will be able to make informed decisions if you can clearly explain their differences.Not sure if you should pick up an Igloo,Coleman,Lifetimeor a Yeti cooler? This detailed comparison can help you make up your mind!

Cover Photo:yeti.com
 

About YETI

1659578089460400.png

Source:yeti.com

Yeti was founded by Roy and Ryan Seiders in 2006.Yeti is an American outdoor manufacturer company based in Austin, Texas. Yeti specializes in products such as ice chests, vacuum-insulated stainless-steel drinkware, soft coolers, and related accessories.Over the course of the next 16 years, the brand focused primarily on their collection of hard- and soft-sided coolers, becoming a veritable household name in the cooler industry and acquiring a massive following, but has since expanded into numerous other categories including bags, drinkware, and even a suite of dog-friendly gear.Besides coolers, Yeti also makes tumblers, dry bags, and water bottles.Because of Yeti's popularity, they are able to sell their products at a premium price compared to other similarly made coolers and people will still buy them.

YETI Cooler Review

Yeti Coolers are the ultimate in design, performance and durability. They were created by authentic outdoorsmen who leveraged their experiences afield resulting in a product that exudes simplicity, durability, and quality bound with intelligently designed features. Besides coolers, Yeti also makes tumblers, dry bags, and water bottles.Because of Yeti's popularity, they are able to sell their products at a premium price compared to other similarly made coolers and people will still buy them.

Yeti offers a wide variety of cooler shapes and sizes, both in soft-sided and hard-sided varieties. These coolers have lid latches, hinges, permafrost insulation, among other features that are designed with sportsmen in mind. Furthermore, most yeti coolers are certified bear proof. 

YETI coolers take a long time to build, and they are hand-made in the United States, which is another bonus for people who want to buy American products. The standard warranty for YETI coolers is five years, which is rather impressive compared to the one-year warranty that most coolers come with.If you have ever owned a YETI Cooler before, then you know how well they hold up over time. Most of the time, you do not have to worry about replacing your YETI cooler because they are built to last.

Where to Buy:

Money Saving Tip:

If you like online shopping, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux!(What is Extrabux) , then you can enjoy up to 30+% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus! Student Benefits:As long as you are a student at school, you can get a free whole year long VIP Card worth $199

You can save on buying daily necessities, outdorr gear,fashion, beauty, electronic products, broadband installation, mobile communication, air tickets, hotels and other aspects of life! 

Extrabux.com cooperates with many merchants, such as: Walmart (Up to 4% cashback), Sephora(4% -5% cash back),Dior (Up to 6% cash back), Moosejaw (5% -6% cash back), LOOKFANTASTIC (Up to 10% cash back), Microsoft (Up to 7% cash back) and so on.

The Best Yeti Cooler

#YETI Tundra Haul

Price: $400

Color: 5 options

Capacity: 55-quart

The Yeti Tundra Haul Hard Cooler is expensive, but when you’re choosing a wheeled model, it’s worth paying for hardware that won’t break or strain under heavy loads.The arm of the Tundra Haul is made from a thick-gauge welded aluminum.The wheels are a single-construction plastic and not hollow or feeble-feeling as on so many other coolers. This cooler feels like you can roll it across anything without the handle straining or bending, or the wheels breaking.

Keeping our perishables cool, including two litre bottles stored upright, space for 45 cans of beer in total or 55 pounds of ice, the Yeti Tundra Haul one offers two inches of pressure injected insulation. 

Product Feature Image

Source:yeti.com

ProsCons
  • Extremely durable for use in tough conditions and rough terrain.

  • High-quality materials and construction for long-lasting use.

  • The wheels are easy to maneuver on uneven and bumpy terrain.

  • The cooler is bear-proof to keep you safe during camping.

  • The latches are heavy-duty and easy to quickly use when opening or shutting your cooler.

  • Heavy for its size.

  • Expensive when compared to other similar choices on the market.

  • The handle is not the most ergonomic and can be a bit tedious to use.

About Igloo

1659582441406138.png

Source:amazon.com

Born from a modest metalworking shop back in 1947, Igloo has been instrumental in redefining how we live, work and play. What began with bringing clean water to the worksite quickly moved into super-functional, best in class ice chests. Igloo products made the family outdoor recreation movement of the 20th century possible. With more than 500 products sold at hundreds of retailers around the globe,Igloo has became  the number one cooler manufacturer in the world.

Igloo Cooler Review

Igloo offers a HUGE array of cooler sizes and also makes a product for just about every environment and application. They provide a model for every situation, keeping food and drinks nice and chilled throughout the longest summer parties, making battling the summer sun a breeze.In fact, they likely have the most impressive overall collection of coolers in the industry. They have simple, lightweight lunchboxes for those needing to simply pack an individual lunch up to huge Polar coolers that can store enough food and drinks for an entire family reunion.  They also have mobile, soft-sided products that are intended for the office life and they have Super Tough STX coolers that are made to take a serious beating in the great outdoors.  Each product has a lasting 5-year warranty to assure customers of quality and performance.

Whether hiking, partying, or taking a trip to see the grandparents, Igloo Coolers are around to ensure the journey is comfortable, relaxed, and joyful.

Where to Buy:

The Best Igloo Cooler

#igloo IMX 70 Qt Cooler

Price: $299.99

Color: 7 options

Capacity: 70-quart

Lightweight yet heavy-duty! igloo's top-performance, super durable IMX cooler features Ultratherm® insulation that provides advanced ice retention and weighs 40% less than coolers with similar performance. Thanks to the built-in features — like a bottle opener, cup holders, lockable lid, fish ruler and wire basket — the spacious 70-quart IMX is the bestselling cooler countless adventurers rely on.

1659593075583485.png

Source:igloocoolers.com

ProsCons
  • Plenty of features.

  • Beefy construction,.

  • Solid insulation.

Bulky for its internal capacity.

Doesn't seal.

Poor drain design.

About Coleman

Source:coleman.com

The Coleman Company, Inc. is an American brand of outdoor recreation products, especially camping gear, now owned by Newell Brands. The company's new headquarters are in Chicago, and it has facilities in Wichita, Kansas, and in Texas. Coleman has over 120 years of expertise in developing innovative outdoor and camping equipment. Coleman offers a wide range of outdoor products. Coleman offers everything from coolers to drinkware, furniture to tents, and other car camping equipment. They are a well-respected company.Coleman gear is everywhere you are: on the trail, by the lake, at the match, or in the middle of a music festival. 

Coleman Cooler Review

Coleman invented coolers in 1954 with a steel belter cooler and later started making plastic coolers a few years later.Coleman has a great range of cooler sizes, starting at personal-sized coolers that are intended for an individual to pack his or her lunch to gigantic coolers that are large enough to store an entire week’s worth of items or supplies for a huge tailgate.  All sizes are optimally shaped, meaning that you should be able to use a vast majority of the storage volume.

Many of Coleman’s coolers have helpful little features or accessories built into the coolers to make things as convenient as possible. Examples of this include features such as molded cup holders, easy-access lids, multiple carrying methods, stacking capabilities, and much more.  A lot of these unique twists and features you won’t find any many competing brands.

No matter if you are looking for a marine cooler, a beach cooler, a pool cooler, a hunting cooler, or any other application you could think of, Coleman has a product for you.  

Where to Buy:

The Best Coleman Cooler

#Coleman70-Quart Xtreme 5-Day Hard Cooler

Price: $64.99

Color: 1 option

Capacity: 70-quart

Food and drinks—and the fun—last longer at the campsite or tailgate with the Coleman 70-Quart Xtreme 5-Day Hard Cooler. It Keeps the Ice up to 5 days in temperatures as high as 90°F, to be exact.Xtreme technology uses an insulated lid and extra insulation in the walls for longer ice retention.You'll appreciate the no-crush comfort-grip side handles that allow for pinch-free carrying.

Costing less than a quarter of most of the competition, while still boasting decent insulation and pretty good usability.It's not airtight, leakproof, lockable, or particularly durable, but it can get you through a weekend and won't break the bank in the process.

1659593855203974.png

Source:walmart.com

ProsCons
  • Super lightweight.

  • Decent insulation for the price

  • surprisingly large capacity.

  • inexpensive.

  • Not airtight.

  • Not particularly durable.

  • Uncomfortable handles.

About Lifetime

Lifetime is a brand, and they make coolers. Actually, this brand is known for making a lot of different products, ranging from tables and chairs to sports gear.

As a dedicated father and fan of basketball, Lifetime Products' founder simply wanted to build a better basketball hoop for his family.His passion for innovation quickly expanded beyond his initial project, and he created a company in March of 1986 called Lifetime Products. The philosophy for the name, as well as the goal of the company, was to build durable lasting products for consumers and their families.Lifetime Products became a world-wide trusted brand as it quickly broadened from basketball hoops to picnic tables, then folding tables and chairs. From those first years in Lifetime's history, the company has grown from 15 employees in a partial warehouse to over 1,500 employees — all over the globe.

1659583041615585.png

Source:lifetime.com

Lifetime Cooler Review

Lifetime coolers are a budget friendly option to Yeti coolers and have many of the same features but cost a fraction of the cost.For under $100 at Walmart you can get a cooler that can hold ice for up to 5 days and is strong, durable and bear proof. It’s also made locally in the USA.This is a great option for the budget shopper who wants something better than a standard cooler, but doesn’t want to pay the hefty price tag of a high-end cooler.Their coolers are made from roto-molded plastic, which makes it very durable and strong. Its rugged appearance shows that it was built to withstand the most severe conditions.

Lifetime Coolers have also had their ice chests certified Grizzly Bear proof by the IGBC. Its one-mold construction ensures that it can withstand bear attacks and drops. While Lifetime did manage to hit the largest target markets, the overall size choices are still a bit lacking. Missing is a large range of mid-sized coolers and there are no choices for those of you who are after huge coolers (100+ quarts of storage volume).

Where to Buy:

The Best Lifetime Cooler 

#Lifetime 55 Quart High Performance Cooler

Price: $134.10

Color: 1 option

Capacity: 70-quart

The Lifetime High Performance Cooler is perfect for anywhere you want to go. Its performance exceeds most premium priced coolers both in strength and in the all-important ice retention. With an insulated lid and body that provides strength, protection, and insulation, the Lifetime cooler is light enough for everyday use, solid enough to keep your ice, and durable enough to go anywhere you go. With a 5-year warranty, up to 7 days ice retention, and room for 60 cans with ice, the Lifetime cooler will more than stack up with the competition.

1659595088683732.png

Source:amazon.com

ProsCons
  • Heavy-duty polyethylene construction.

  • Two rubber latches on either side of the front hold the lid in place. 

  • Easy-to-drain spout.

  • This cooler is built to last long and this is definitely one of it’s best features.

  • Budget friendly.

  • This cooler can hold up to 60 cans together with ice. 

  • No accessories.

  • No option of fitting wheels to the cooler.

  • It is not watertight.

Yeti vs. Igloo vs. Coleman vs. Lifetime: Comparison Side by Side

1.Ice Retention

Yeti coolers - Based on reviews and feedback from its customers, on average, YETI coolers can keep ice for up to 7 days. This is on par with other top-of-the-line brands.

Igloo coolers - Igloo claims the cooler can retain ice for 4 to 5 days at temperatures up to 90 degrees Fahrenheit, and based on Amazon customer reviews, it seems to live up to the hype.

Coleman coolers - If you pre-chill the cooler and if your beverages are already cold when you stack them in the cooler, they will keep your beverages cold up to 5 days (depends on a lot of factors though, such as outside temperature).

Lifetime coolers - Lifetime advertises 7-day ice retention.However it is more likely to get 5+ days ice retention in hotter weather and around about 7-8 days ice retention in cooler weather. There are a lot of reviews on YouTube by actual customers putting it at a much lower figure of between 3 and 4 days.

2.Sizes & Capacity

Yeti coolers - YETI cooler models and their capacity based on number of beers and pounds of ice.

image.png

image.png

As far as size range goes, a YETI cooler definitely has the upper hand for selection. They have way more sizes available, from the 20 quart model up to a massive 350 quarts (designed for fishermen and hunters). 

Igloo coolers - Igloo coolers have 4 size options:

  • Small - Up to 20qt

  • Medium - 21-50qt

  • Large - 51-100qt

  • X-Large - 101+qt

Coleman coolers - Coleman has a great range of cooler sizes, starting at personal-sized coolers that are intended for an individual to pack his or her lunch to gigantic coolers that are large enough to store an entire week’s worth of items or supplies for a huge tailgate.  All sizes are optimally shaped, meaning that you should be able to use a vast majority of the storage volume.

Some specific attributes and qualities would benefit one size more than another and Coleman has a good understanding of what modifications to make to their design based on its size.

Lifetime coolers - Lifetime currently has three different cooler sizes to choose from. All three models are hard-sided. You can choose from 28-quart, 55-quart, and 77-quart options.

3.Design & Color

Yeti coolers - While Yeti’s core design is considered by many to be more than adequate, they go beyond and offer a wide range of color choices and some patterns and they even now offer various products that are adorned with sports teams.  They also have special services where you can have custom logos made for work, sports, and or any other organization you are a part of. 

Igloo coolers - They offer a wide range of color choices and some patterns.

Coleman coolers - Coleman has a huge selection of style attributes to choose from. This doesn’t just stop at the color selection.  External patterns and color schemes and even attractive metal coolers are part of their vast selection.  So for those of you who want something that looks as good as it performs then you should be covered. 

Lifetime coolers - The cooler comes in three colors: gray,white,yellow with blue highlights at the handles and latches.

Comparison Table


Yeti CoolersIgloo CoolersColeman CoolersLifetime Coolers
Hard Coolers
Soft Coolers
Rotomolded Coolers
Price$25 - $1,500$14.99 - $339.99$9.99 - $384.99$125 - $319.99
Warranty5-year1-yearColeman's warranties are not indefinite. The warranty period varies from product to product.up to 5 years
Return PolicyReturns available within 30 days of purchaseReturns available within 60 days of purchaseReturns available within 60 days of purchaseReturns available within 30 days of purchase

Yeti vs. Igloo vs. Coleman vs. Lifetime: Which is the Best Cooler Brand?

It is rather difficult to put these four on the same table because of how different they are. Indeed, Yeti is an undisputed beast with a solid reputation in the industry. If you just want the better overall cooler considering the insulation and ice retention, you can go with the YETI. 

Coleman is the better option for those who have a small budget but yet need a good ice retention performance and handy features such as cup holders, wheels, etc. Igloo on the other hand is the better brand for those who need a bit high-end, more heavy-duty, sportive cooler.

When it comes to value for money you really can't go wrong with the Lifetime cooler.For the price you are paying you get almost all the features of a Yeti cooler. Sure it lacks some of the durability and it isn't watertight.

Hydro Flask vs. Corkcicle vs. YETI vs. Frost Buddy Koozie: Which Makes the Best Can Cooler?

YETI vs. RTIC vs. Pelican vs. ORCA: Which Brand Wins the Cooler Showdown?

BruMate vs. YETI vs. RTIC vs. Swig Can Cooler: Which Brand Wins the Koozie Showdown?

Thermos vs. Stanley vs. Yeti: Which Brand is Best for Vacuum Flask?

Hydro Flask vs. Yeti vs. S'well vs. Klean Kanteen: Which Brand is Best for Water Bottle?

9
2022-08-03 20:196532