Home
>
Guide
>
Raise vs. CardCash vs. Gift Card Granny: Full Comparison & Verdict 2024

It contains affiliate links and Extrabux will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on Extrabux links.

Raise vs. CardCash vs. Gift Card Granny: Full Comparison & Verdict 2024

No matter you want to buy a gift card as a birthday gift for your friends or you prepare to turn your unwanted gift cards that go into a desk drawer and be forgotten for years into cash, the online gift cards exchange site is the easiest and quickest option. Raise, CardCash, and Gift Card Granny are the three most popular gift card sites on the market currently. But where is the best place to sell gift cards among the three? Which site is best for you to buy discount gift cards? In this guide, I will take a look at some of the features the Raise, the CardCash, and the Gift Card Granny have in common, as well as point out some noticeable differences between them to help you make the right decision. Therefore, let’s get straight into this Raise vs. CardCash vs. Gift Card Granny side-by-side comparison.

Cover Photo:giftcardgranny.com

Raise vs. CardCash vs. Gift Card Granny Side-by-Side Comparison

	Raise	CardCash	Gift Card Granny
Payment Options
Venmo Payment Support	No	No	No
Debit & Prepaid Card Support	Yes	No	Yes
PayPal Support	Yes	Yes	Yes
Apple Pay Support	Yes	No	No
Google Pay Support	Yes	No	No
Amazon Pay Support	No	No	No
Cryptocurrency Support	Yes	Yes	No
Gift Card Support	Yes	Yes	No
Shipping & Returns Policies
Free Shipping Policies	Yes	Yes	No
Free Return Policies	No	No	No
In-store Pickup	No	No	No
Gift Wrapping Services	No	No	No
Order Tracking Support	Yes	Yes	Yes
Order Tracking Support	No	No	No
Modification & Cancellation Policies	No	Yes	No
Coupons & Discounts
Email Discounts	No	No	No
Price Adjustment Policies	No	No	No
Coupon Stacking Policies	No	No	No
Competitor Coupon Policies	No	No	No
Price Matching Policies	No	No	No
Customer-Specific Discounts
AAA Discount	No	No	No
Senior Discount Policies	No	No	No
Veteran's Discount Policies	Yes	No	No
Student Discount Policies	Yes	No	No
Company Values, Ethics & Policies
Positive Brand Values	Yes	No	No
Ethical Supply Chain	No	No	No
Sustainability Commitment	No	No	No
Commitment to Racial Equity	No	No	No
Privacy Policy & Data Security
Privacy Policies	Yes	No	No
Data Portability Policies	No	No	No
Security Features & Policies	Yes	No	No
Loyalty, Rewards & Partnership Programs
Influencer Marketing Programs	No	No	No
Loyalty Programs	No	No	No

Raise vs. CardCash vs. Gift Card Granny: Review

1. Raise

Primary Benefit: Easy-to-Use Site

Range: $5 to $2,000
Up to 85% Return Rate
You Set the Selling Price
Payment Issued Via Direct Deposit, PayPal, or Check

Sample Payouts for $100 Gift Cards

Walmart Gift Card = $84.34
Best Buy Gift Card = $83.82
Target Gift Card = $83.83

Raise is one of the largest discount gift card websites, with over 2 million buyers and sellers using the platform. Since 2013, card buyers have saved over $150 million. It offers discounts of up to 30% on gift cards from more than 1,000 merchants including Amazon、eBay、Kohl's、T.J Maxx and Airbnb etc. Some gift cards at Raise.com are only available as eGift cards, which means you can only use them for online purchases. The site also sells physical gift cards and printable vouchers. To get a physical gift card by mail, shipping is free.

Listing an electronic gift card is free. Raise charges a 15% sales commission based on the transaction price. Though, a physical gift card is charged an additional listing fee, the greater of 1% or $2.75 based on its balance. For example, if you're selling a $100 physical gift card that sells for $80, the sales commission is $12, the listing fee is $2.75, and Raise will pay you $65.25.

Source:raise.com

What makes Raise different than other places is that you can set your own selling price. For example, if you have a $100 Best Buy gift card to sell and another person is selling theirs for $98, you can list yours at $97.99 to become the lowest priced listing and make a quick sale! When a card is sold, you can be paid via direct deposit, PayPal, or check. They also offer a one-year money-back guarantee that covers cards that aren't active, have an inaccurate balance, are delivered as a different brand than ordered, or cards that aren't received within 30 days from the date of purchase.

PROS	CONS
The website and app are free and easy to use	Charge Raise's 15% selling fee
The high volume of brands	More complex for sellers than competitors
Significant discounts are sometimes available
Raise's referral program allows users to earn a $5 credit toward future gift card purchases
BBB accredited with an impressive A rating
1-year money-back guarantee

Extrabux Cashback: If you want to buy discount gift cards from Raise, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux (What is Extrabux?), then you can enjoy up to 2% super cashback from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get a $20 welcome bonus!

2. CardCash

Primary Benefit: Trades Earn Up to 13.5% More

Range: $1 and up
Up to 92% Return Rate
Payment Issued Via Direct Deposit, PayPal, or Check
Offers Amazon Gift Cards

Sample Payouts for $100 Gift Cards

iTunes Gift Card = $66 (or a Gift Card Trade worth up to $74.91)
Walmart Gift Card = $89 (or a Gift Card Trade worth up to $101.02)
Best Buy Gift Card = $87 (or a Gift Card Trade worth up to $98)
Target Gift Card = $82.15 (or a Gift Card Trade worth up to $93)

CardCash.com acquired one of its discount gift card competitors, PlasticJungle, in 2014. The site has plenty of gift cards on offer from more than 550-merchants. Some of the cards come with discounts as high as 35%, and you also get plenty of options for physical cards as well. If you do order a physical card, the site ships it to you via USPS, with delivery times ranging from 5 to 7-days, but the shipping is free.

Whether you’re looking for apparel, toys, home improvement, or hundreds of other brands, you can find gift card options for less at Cardcash.com. In addition, CardCash also offers a 100% risk-free money-back guarantee on all pre-owned discounted gift cards used within 45 days of its purchase, so you’ll be protected as a buyer.

Source:cardcash.com

If you're looking to sell your gift card, CardCash is also a good option. The rates offered by CardCash were higher than most competitors. Selling gift cards at CardCash is easy: Simply enter a merchant and card balance, and you can see your offer instantly. You can also add multiple cards at once and see their total value. Only gift cards with a remaining balance of $10 or more are eligible. You can receive their money within 1-2 business days of the order approval. You can choose to receive the payment via ACH deposit, PayPal, or snail mail.

PROS	CONS
User-friendly app	Cards only guaranteed for 45 days
Very low fees charged to sellers	Decent but not amazing BBB rating
Big discounts available
Several payment options to choose from when it comes to getting your money after selling a gift card

Extrabux Cashback: Up to 2% super cashback!

3. Gift Card Granny

Primary Benefit: Huge Selection

Range: Unlimited
Up to 92% Return Rate
Compares Payout Amounts From Various Gift Card Exchanges
Payment Issued Via Direct Deposit, PayPal, or Check

Sample Payouts for $100 Gift Cards

iTunes Gift Card = $75.58
Walmart Gift Card = $90
Best Buy Gift Card = $88.50
Target Gift Card = $86

Unlike other websites, like Raise and CardCash, Gift Card Granny doesn’t actually ship or sell gift cards itself – instead, it connects buyers and sellers of discounted gift cards. It gathers the best deals from dozens of gift card exchange websites. You’ll find cheap gift cards from popular brands like Target, Starbucks, Forever 21, and Sephora for as much as 17% off. Gift Card Granny will redirect you to a site where you can get paid instantly.

The discounts found on Gift Card Granny can be better than those on other sites. That’s because Gift Card Granny sells full-priced cards directly from the merchants with guarantees as well as used cards from individual sellers and resellers that come with a more limited guarantee. Gift Card Granny also shows cards from other sites so is a good place to start your search when looking for the cheapest gift cards.

Source:giftcardgranny.com

At Gift Card Granny you can buy plastic or printable gift cards to be used online or in brick-and-mortar locations of all kinds. Besides getting discount gift cards, Gift Card Granny also has a loyalty program. You earn points for buying gift cards and opening sponsored emails. These points can be redeemed for gift cards in the future! You can sell your card if you need cash fast. The payment methods are typically Zelle, check, PayPal, direct deposit, or bank wire. It is also possible to get a higher payment if you want to wait it out.

PROS	CONS
Informative and user-friendly website, with an additional option of an app	It won't buy your gift card (but it’ll help you sell it elsewhere)
Cards are offered in various forms, for example as online codes or physical cards	Depending on how you want to get paid, it will typically take up to a week to receive your funds
The cashback option means you save money on every purchase
Recently BBB accredited with an impressive A- rating

Verdict

If you want to sell your cards quickly, you may want to visit Raise. The site is vast. It’s my go-to, and I think it's one of the best places to sell gift cards electronically online. But pay attention that it will cost you more to sell gift cards (charge 15% fee) here than via Raise’s competitors.

One of the big advantages of CardCash is that the rates offered by it were higher than most competitors, and it has very low fees charged to sellers, so if you have a lot of unwanted gift cards to sell and want to get the best value, CardCash is a better choice.

The cool thing about Gift Card Granny is that the site shows you multiple offers from different gift card marketplaces — and it has an incredible selection if you’re looking to buy gift cards at a discount. But unlike Raise and CardCash, whilst Gift Card Granny posts lots of useful, informative content and has many gift cards listed available to buy, it doesn’t offer you the chance to sell your gift card.

All in all, all three gift card trading sites have their own unique strengths. So before buying or selling gift cards, I strongly recommend that you check out these three gift card websites one by one to get the best deals.