Home
>
Guide
>
Nature Made vs. Nature's Way vs. Solaray vs. Garden of Life: Which Wins the Vitamin & Mineral Brand Showdown?

It contains affiliate links and Extrabux will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on Extrabux links.

Nature Made vs. Nature's Way vs. Solaray vs. Garden of Life: Which Wins the Vitamin & Mineral Brand Showdown?

Vitamins and minerals are essential nutrients because they perform hundreds of roles in the body. These nutrients work in symphony to grow, heal, repair and maintain your body's cells, organs, systems and skeleton. Eating a healthy diet is the best way to get sufficient amounts of the vitamins and minerals you need. But if you’re unable to meet your nutritional needs through your diet alone, supplements can be a convenient and effective way to do so. Anyone that has been looking for the best vitamin & mineral supplements might have heard of Nature Made, Nature's Way, Solaray, and Garden of Life. But which one makes the best vitamin & mineral supplement brand? Therefore in this Nature's Way vs. Nature Made vs. Solaray vs. Garden of Life comparison, we want to look at four brands from top to bottom. This includes their ithird-party lab, certification, ingredients, quality and efficacy, pros & cons, customer service, and more!

1. Nature Made Reviews

At Nature Made, they create thoughtfully designed products to fit your lifestyle needs at every stage.

Nature Made is the brand consumers trust for their daily vitamins and can be found in almost any grocery store. This is the reason why they have a lot of customers who use them for their health products.

Some of their notable products include a fish oil supplement, a melatonin supplement, and multivitamin tablets. They are also known because they utilize unique combinations of vitamins to create their supplements.

Nature Made creates products for all kinds of people, including pregnant women, senior citizens, athletes, and those who need to lose weight.

Moreover, Nature Made has added natural fruit flavors to some of its products to make them more appealing to the customers.

Source:naturemade.com

Pros & Cons

Pros:

Nature Made offers several vitamins and supplements that have USP verification and the #1 Pharmacist Recommended seal.
NSF GMP-certified.
With subscription plan: subscribe & save 10% + free shipping.

Cons:

Nature Made offers fewer promotions.

Quality and Efficacy

With Nature Made you can rest assured that you are taking vitamins and supplements that are manufactured to FDA standards in an NSF GMP-certified facility that meets accepted industry processes and procedures.

Nature Made’s high-quality standards extend to every aspect of its business-from sourcing ingredients, through product manufacturing, packaging, and shipping, right up to product sale and after-service assistance.

In fact, Nature Made boasts that they have the largest number of USP verified products and are the number 1 recommended brand by Pharmacists.

USP (The United States Pharmacopeia)

The United States Pharmacopeia (USP) is the national public standards-setting authority for all prescription and over-the-counter medicines, dietary supplements, and medical devices for human use. Using scientific procedures and methods, the standards have been set to protect and improve public health. As a nonprofit organization, USP’s mission is to ensure that the medicines Americans depend on are safe, effective, and of high quality. Since 1820, USP has been developing public standards for medicines, to ensure their identity, strength, quality, and purity. Products labeled with USP Verified mark conform to the quality standards for identity, strength, quality, and purity established by USP. As a nonprofit organization, USP’s mission is to ensure that the medicines Americans depend on are safe, effective, and of high quality.

FDA (U.S. Food and Drug Administration)

The FDA is responsible for protecting public health. The FDA ensures that products are safe and properly labeled. That’s why you can be confident that vitamins made in the U.S.A. meet or exceed the quality standards set by FDA for safety, purity, and efficacy.

NSF & GMP (National Sanitation Foundation) GMP (Good Manufacturing Practices)

Certification is a certification that ensures purity from the manufacturing facility to the consumer. All manufacturers with NSF GMP Certification are required to follow strict guidelines in all areas of facility and product cleanliness, testing protocols, raw materials, facility maintenance, air quality, equipment, and instrument calibration through a rigorous inspection by NSF GAP Certified Inspectors.

So as you can see, when Nature Made says they have the largest number of USP verified products, are manufacturer to FDA standards, and are certified with national sanitation and good manufacturing practices, it is a big deal and speaks volumes about the quality of this brand and their products.

Product: Vitamins

Nature Made not only provides multivitamins, but also vitamin B, C, D, E, K and more.

Multivitamins

A multivitamin is like your daily nutrition insurance policy. Multivitamins are an easy way to provide a range of essential nutrients in a daily supplement. Multivitamins provide key essential vitamins and minerals to meet or exceed your daily needs. Nature Made multivitamins are specially formulated with age, gender and life stage in mind.

1. Multivitamin + Omega-3 Gummies	Provides key nutrients that your body needs daily and heart-healthy omega-3s in a delicious gummy form. So you can look out for your heart and your taste buds.
2. Men’s Multivitamins	Nature Made men’s multivitamins are made based on the general recommended intake for men during specific life stages.
3. Women’s Multivitamins	Nature Made women’s multivitamins are made based on the general recommended intake for women during specific life stages. Multivitamins for women are essential nutrients that women need daily. Whether you just turned 18, you just celebrated your 80th birthday, or you're somewhere in between, Nature Made has a formula for you.
4. Kids Multivitamins	Nature Made Kids First multivitamins are designed to help fill key nutrient gaps in kids’ diets. Nature Made Kids First multivitamins are a great way for your kids to take their vitamins and actually enjoy them! These delicious kids multivitamin gummies come in natural fruit flavors and are packed with essential daily nutrients to support your child’s wellness. They offer a range of vitamins and minerals each with their own unique role in the body, including Vitamin D to help support healthy bone and tooth development, and Vitamin A to support healthy eye function. Plus, Vitamin C and Zinc, two key nutrients to support immune health at every age.
5. Prenatal & Postnatal Multivitamins	Nature Made prenatal and postnatal multivitamins are designed to support baby’s development and mom’s overall health.

Vitamins

When your diet calls for a little more B, C, D, E or K, Nature Made has you covered.

B Vitamins
B Complex
Biotin
Vitamin C
Vitamin D
Vitamin E
Folic Acid
Vitamin K

Product: Minerals

At Nature Made, they offer a variety of different mineral supplements to complement your lifestyle. Each dietary supplement is made from quality ingredients, and their selection of mineral supplements includes calcium, iron, potassium, magnesium, and zinc. They also offer various mineral forms to choose from like tablets, gummies, capsules and softgels. Support your health by adding minerals to your daily routine.

Calcium
Iron
Magnesium
Potassium
Zinc

Customer Service

Click here to email a Nature Made expert with your question, or call them at 1-800-276-2878.

Return Policy

If you are not completely satisfied with your product, you may request a refund of your payment (less any applicable shipping fees) or a replacement within 30 days of receipt. This policy is only applicable for products purchased from them directly at www.naturemade.com. If you purchased from a different retailer please refer directly to their return/refund policy.

To receive your refund or replacement, please contact them or email them at info@naturemade.com. For faster service, please have your order confirmation number and your original packaging available. They may also request that you return your product, although such return is not required in order for you to receive your refund or replacement.

Please allow 5 – 7 business days for your refund to process. Your refund will be processed to original payment method provided at time of purchase. Please allow 7 – 10 business days to receive your replacement product, if you have requested a replacement. Due to item availability, some replacements may be delayed or changed to a refund.

Please note that your refund will be subject to an $8.00 shipping fee if your total order was less than $25.00 or if your order was shipped outside the contiguous 48 states.

Where to Buy Vitamin & Mineral Supplements?

You can buy vitamin & mineral supplements at brands' official website (like Nature Made.com, 10% Super Cash Back from Extrabux). You can also go iHerb.com, Walmart.com, Walgreens or Amazon.com to purchase vitamin & mineral supplements.

Saving Tip: If you like online shopping, don't forget to sign up at Extrabux！(What is Extrabux) , then you can enjoy up to 30+% cashback on your purchase from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus! Student Benefits：As long as you are a student at school, you can get a free whole year long VIP Card worth $199.

Extrabux.com cooperates with many merchants, such as: Walmart (Up to 4% cashback), Sephora（4% -5% cash back), Moosejaw (5% -6% cash back), LOOKFANTASTIC (Up to 10% cash back), Giorgio Armani Beauty(10-12% cashback) )Sam's Club (Up to 15% cashback), Norton(Up to 20% cashback), Microsoft (Up to 7% cash back) and so on. You can save on buying daily necessities, fashion, beauty, electronic products, broadband installation, mobile communication, air tickets, hotels and other aspects of life!

12 Cheapest Places to Buy Supplements & Nutrition Online 2024

Health and fitness supplements are ex...

438145

Nature Made Promotions

1. Subscribe 10% Off + Free Shipping. Click here to check best sellers.

2. Nature's Way

Nature’s Way claims to cater to the vitamin needs of Australians through a mix of traditional and modern medicine options. For more than 50 years, they have been driven by one mission: to help people everywhere live healthy lives. It provides a broad spectrum of health supplements, including superfoods, sport and fitness, and weight loss/management products.

Nature’s Way provides plenty of ways to get the whole family to take their vitamins, offering supplements in the form of drops, milk buttons, chewable capsules, powders, yoghurts and chocolate balls. There are additionally herbal and wholefoods mixtures such as capsules and powders claimed to address a broad spectrum of health concerns, including arthritis, bone strength, brain health, immunity, digestion, stress, cardiovascular health and beauty.

Source:naturesway.com

Pros & Cons

Pros:

TRU-ID certification.
Non-GMO.
Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) facility by NSF.
Consciously Crafted, Expert Verified.
Provides a comprehensive range of vitamins and minerals.

Cons:

No subscription plan.
The shopping guide on the official website is not as good as the Nature Made website.

Quality and Efficacy

1. Nature’s Way is the first big brand to pass TRU-ID certification. Passing TRU-ID verification can ensure that the ingredients listed on the product label are consistent with the ingredients in the product.

2. Nature’s Way is committed to providing non-GMO products, by cooperating with the only non-GMO project in North America, to ensure that the products do not contain GMO ingredients. The products with the NON-GMO Project VERIFIED logo printed on the bottle are all non-GMO products.

3. Nature’s Way was the first recognized Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) facility by NSF and continue to set the bar for the industry today. They are leaders of groups including the Council of Responsible Nutrition and the Natural Products Association, organizations that continue to elevate dietary supplement standards to ensure better products for all.

4. Nature’s Way goes above and beyond to ensure what’s on the label is what’s in your bottle. Their team of professionals performs thorough testing on raw materials and every batch of product in their onsite state-of-the-art lab, an investment that’s a rarity in the industry. They approach quality from all angles, meticulously implementing chemical testing, identity testing, microbiological testing and more. Their robust testing program ensures that their products meet every regulatory standard including California’s Proposition 65.

Product: Multivitamins

Nature’s Way multivitamins are specially formulated with age, gender and life stage in mind. Multivitamins tailored for women, men and children. Multivitamins in gummy, tablet and capsule form. Best Sellers:

1. Alive! Once Daily, Women's Ultra Potency Complete Multivitamin	Alive! Once Daily Women’s Ultra Potency is a complete multivitamin formulated to support your multitasking lifestyle with 100% or more of the Daily Value of 20 vitamins and minerals and 200% or more of the Daily Value of 12 vitamins and minerals, including premium B-vitamins to convert food into cellular energy – all in one convenient tablet.
2. Alive! Once Daily Men’s Ultra Potency Multivitamin	Alive! Once Daily Men’s Ultra Potency is a complete multivitamin formulated to support your go-getting lifestyle with 100% or more of Daily Value of 19 vitamins and minerals and 200% or more of Daily Value of 13 vitamins and minerals, including premium B-vitamins to convert food into cellular energy so you can hit the trails, hang with your family, and feel your best for every moment.
3. Alive! Men's 50+ Ultra Potency	Feel energized and alive for every moment with this ultra-potent daily multivitamin formulated specially for men age 50+. It’s made with 100% or more of the Daily Value of 19 vitamins and minerals and 200% or more of the Daily Value of 12 vitamins and minerals including premium B-vitamins to convert food into fuel. This complete formula supports bone health, eye health, heart health, immune health, muscle function, and energy metabolism, making it a simple way to support your general nutrition and health every day.
4. Alive! Women’s Energy Complete Multivitamin	This high potency multivitamin is formulated with 100% Daily Value of 20 essential vitamins and minerals, including boron and lutein. Plus, it’s packed with high potency B-vitamins to support your daily cellular energy.
5. Alive! Premium Women’s Gummy Multivitamin	This multivitamin is made with 16 vitamins and minerals, plus the full B-vitamin complex to convert the food you eat into cellular energy. A daily dose supports your heart health, skin health, immune health, and bone health.

Product: Vitamins & Minerals

They’re the building blocks of wellness. Shop high-quality single vitamins and minerals for a variety of wellness needs.

Calcium + D3
Vitamin C
Vitamin D
Zinc
Magnesium
Niacinamide
Selenium
Riboflavin
Potassium
Vitamin B12
Iron
Vitamin E
and so on

Customer Service

If you cannot find the answer you need, please call Nature's Way on 0333 800 8073 or fill in the form on this page to send Nature's Way a message. Their phone line is open is open Monday to Friday 8am-8.30pm, Saturdays 9am to 5pm and Sundays 10am to 5pm. Closed on Bank Holidays.

Return Policy

Nature's Way wants you to be confident in the Nature’s Way product you’ve selected for your wellness routine. If for any reason you are not satisfied with a Nature’s Way product you purchased for personal use from them or one of their authorized sellers, they want to make it right. You can request a refund or replacement product within 45 days of purchase, as long as your product came from a them or a Nature’s Way authorized seller within the United States.

To obtain a refund for product purchased directly on Naturesway.com, or if you are unable to obtain a refund from the authorized seller from which you purchased your product, please call one of their customer service representatives at 1-800-962-8873. Please have information available regarding where and when you purchased your product. Upon approval of your request, you will then need to mail your Nature’s Way product, a proof of purchase (such as your receipt), and your Guarantee approval confirmation number to:

Nature’s Way Brands
Attn: Customer Service
825 Challenger Dr.
Green Bay, WI 54311

Nature's Way Promotions

1. Free Shipping on Orders Over $25.

3. Solaray

Solaray was founded in 1973, acquired by Nutraceutical in 1993 and was a pioneer in the creation and development of blended herbal products. In 1984 Solaray expanded to become a full line manufacturer and began carrying not only quality herbs but also a complete line of vitamins, minerals and other specialty products.

Solaray products are produced under cGMP guidelines and avoid using artificial flavoring, sweetening, or preservatives, though their manufacturing facilities are not NSF GMP-Registered. Solaray supplements offer a wide-ranging catalog with a strong focus on botanical and herbal blends but also include such products as probiotics, minerals, and vitamins.

Source:solaray.com

Pros & Cons

Pros:

Solaray products are produced under cGMP guidelines and avoid using artificial flavoring, sweetening, or preservatives.
With subscription plan: subscribe & save 20%.

Cons:

Manufacturing facilities are not NSF GMP-Registered.
Mineral types are only Calcium, Magnesium, and Zinc.

Quality and Efficacy

1. Powerful Protection	Liposomes have a unique structure that allows them to encase vitamins, minerals, and herbs in a protective barrier—making them an effective vessel for nutrient delivery.
2. Enhanced Absorption	Liposomes surround 100% of the nutrients in a layer of protection, helping them survive the harsh stomach environment to actually reach and be used by cells.
3. Groundbreaking Technology	Instead of delivering liposomes in the traditional liquid format, Solaray’s advanced, proprietary approach dehydrates them into a powder and can be used with convenient capsules.
4. Liposomes Defined	Liposomes are small bubbles of phospholipids, the same fats that make up human cells.
5. High Potency	Their proprietary liposomal process combined with their stringent quality testing protocols means you can rest assured you’re getting an efficacious formula that delivers exactly what’s listed on its label. Liposomes also act gently on the digestive system, for a multivitamin you can truly feel comfortable taking.

Product: Vitamins

Solaray not only provides multivitamins, but also vitamin A, B, C, D, E, and K.

Multivitamins

Same with Nature Made and Nature's Way, Solaray multivitamins are specially formulated with age, gender (men's & women's) and life stage in mind (baby, and kids'). Best sellers:

1. Once Daily Adult 50+ Multivitamin	Complete with powerful, sun-grown nutrition, Solaray Adult 50+ Multivitamin provides energizing herbs of eleuthero and astragalus, CoQ10 to help support antioxidant activity, vitamins D-3 & K-2 for healthy heart support, lutein and zeaxanthin for your eyes, and a Proprietary Enzyme Blend for gentle digestion. And because they're committed to superior formulations for maximum benefit, their Adult 50+ Multivitamin uses specially chelated minerals designed for enhanced uptake and efficient utilization.
2. Solaray, Once Daily, Woman Multivitamin	Formulated to meet the unique needs of women, Solaray Once Daily Woman Multivitamin also includes a Hair, Skin, Nails Blend of MSM, l-cysteine and l-methionine along with B-complex vitamins to help support your most beautiful, youthful look. They've also included lutein for healthy eye support and a Proprietary Enzyme Blend for gentle digestion. And with specially chelated mineral complexes designed for enhanced uptake and efficient utilization, you get full-body, whole-woman support.
3. Solaray, Once Daily, High Energy Multivitamin, Iron Free	Solaray Once Daily High Energy Multivitamin is packed with essential vitamins and minerals and helps support both healthy immune system function as well as higher daily energy levels. Specially designed for those who get sufficient iron in their diet, this formula is iron free. Powerfully potent, each 1-VegCap serving contains 100% DV or more of vitamins A, C, D, E, B vitamins and more. And with a Whole Food and Herb Base including alfalfa, dandelion, kelp, and more, you get sun-grown nutrition and quality to help you radiate inside and out.
4. Solaray, Once Daily High Energy Multivitamin	Solaray Once Daily High Energy Multivitamin is packed with essential vitamins and minerals and helps support both healthy immune system function as well as higher daily energy levels. Powerfully potent, each 1-VegCap serving contains 100% DV or more of vitamins A, C, D, E, B vitamins and more. And with a Whole Food and Herb Base of alfalfa, dandelion, horsetail, and more, you get sun-grown nutrition and quality to help you radiate inside and out.

Vitamins

When your diet calls for a little more A, B, C, D, E or K, Solaray has you covered.

Vitamin A
Vitamin B
Vitamin C
Vitamin D
Vitamin E
Vitamin K

Product: Minerals

Solaray provides three minerals:

Customer Service

You can contact Solaray online.

Return Policy

The original receipt or packing slip is required for all returns and exchanges.

30 Days from original purchase date for all eligible products

EcoGear FX reserves the right to deny any return or exchange.

Nonreturnable Items：

Items that are damaged or abused
Items that are missing accessories such as battery chargers, cords and cables
Non-defective special orders
Refund Method

For Online Purchases:

Refunds will be credited to the original credit card or PayPal account.

Returns Tracking

Based on return/exchange patterns, some customers will be warned that subsequent returns and exchanges will not be eligible for returns or exchanges for 90 days or longer.

Solaray Promotions

1. Complimentary Shipping on Orders Over $50.

2. Subscribe & save 20%.

4. Garden of Life

For more than 14 years, Garden of Life’s mission has been Empowering Extraordinary Health. The human body craves the nutrition found in food, and Garden of Life's goal is to feed that need with cleanest, highest quality whole-food ingredients possible. No synthetic nutrients, artificial flavors, sweeteners or chemical preservatives are ever added to their products.

The organic vitamins, doctor-formulated probiotics and plant-powered proteins you'll find in this line provide fuel and nourishment from real fruits, vegetables, herbs and superfoods, with many formulas bearing the USDA Certified Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified seals.

Garden of Life’s commitment to health goes beyond offering some of the most effective nutritional products in the world. Of equal importance is their quest to preserve the integrity of the planet through eco-friendly initiatives and by supporting relevant philanthropic organizations throughout the world in desperate need of help.

Source:gardenoflife.com

Pros & Cons

Pros:

Clean whole food ingredients.
Certified USDA Organic (no toxic pesticides or residues).
Non-GMO Project Verified products (Independent 3rd Party Certification).
Innovative, science-driven formulas.
Certified B-Corp.

Cons:

A little pricey.

Quality and Efficacy

In Regards to Quality Control, Garden of Life Products:

are safely manufactured by cGMP (current Good Manufacturing Practices) third-party audited facilities.
are tested to be safe, conforming to the FDA’s Good Manufacturing Practices and food standards in regulated labs. (These are testing methods that apply to whole food supplements—food for ingredients versus synthetic supplements.)
have a full-time Quality Control Department dedicated to ensuring all appropriate quality practices are met.
are tested by the leading third-party independent testing agency, [agency name].
are up to standards, such as those requiring Certified USDA Organic products that are safe from toxic pesticides and fertilizers.
are meeting standards of the Non-GMO Project and are Non-GMO Project Verified—safe from genetically modified ingredients.
are Certified B-Corp. Certified B Corporations meet the highest standards of overall social and environmental performance, and build a collective voice through the power of the unifying B-Corp brand.

Additionally, our proteins are Trusted for Sport by Informed-Choice—safe for competitive use and free of banned substances.

Furthermore, they launched “first and only” whole food multivitamins in 2014—mykind Organics—which are fingerprint analyzed for each of the botanical ingredients in the proprietary blend.

Click here to find more about Garden of Life certifications.

Product: Vitamins

Garden of Life not only provides multivitamins, but also vitamin A, B, C, D, E, and K.

Ages 40+
Apple Cider Vinegar
Kids & Baby
Letter Vitamins
Men
Multivitamins
Prenatal
Quercetin
Women

Click here to explore Garden of Life Vitamins.

Product: Minerals

Minerals are essential for many functions going on in our bodies. From strong bones and teeth to healthy blood to restful sleep, Garden of Life has the right supplement for you. Garden of Life offers four minerals:

Calcium
Iron
Magnesium
Zinc

Click here to explore Garden of Life Minerals.

Customer Service

You can contact Garden of Life customer support online through their customer contact form. You can also call the customer support line Monday – Friday from 8:30 AM – 6 PM.

Product Inquiries Number: 866-465-0051
Wholesale Number: 800-622-8986
eCommerce Order Number: 800-365-7709

Return Policy

When you receive your item, you must check it as soon as possible following receipt and always before use. You have 14 days to return your order under their 14-day return period policy, which starts on the day after you received the item. It's so simple, please follow the steps set out on their website (please see the section headed 'Returns and Refunds') All items must be returned unused and in the original packaging as they were in when received by you. Please ensure that when you receive an item that you take reasonable care of it when trying it /inspecting it eg. please ensure that any security seals or tags are still intact.