Home
>
Guide
>
7 Best Drugstore Products for Your Eyebrows: Reviews & Swatches

It contains affiliate links and Extrabux will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on Extrabux links.

7 Best Drugstore Products for Your Eyebrows: Reviews & Swatches

Everything falls apart if our brows aren't looking their best. As the popularity of thick brows has grown so has the number of products meant to perfect them. It's difficult to choose one. Today we are going to take a look at some eyebrow pencils which can make you look gorgeous. Here are the reviews and swatches of our top picks brow products of all types. Each one can be found in the beauty aisle at your local drugstore for under $20.

Cover Photo:diana.grytsku on freepik.com

L'Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Definer Pencil

($9.49 at walgreens.com + Up to 6% Cash Back)

The Definer products extremely precise application, similar to other high end brow pencils but at a much lower cost. This dual sided eyebrow pencil comes with a soft crayon tip on one end and a spoolie brush on the other for creating a feathering effect.

Source:walgreens.com

This pencil has a precise tip to help you recreate tiny brow hairs for a defined shape. The product itself it super smooth and looks so nice. For it being in the drug store, it is so nice. This drugstore eyebrow pencil comes in 5 shades - Blonde, Dark Blonde, Light Brunette, Brunette, and Dark Brunette.

Source:target.com

Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil & Gel

($6.29 at walmart.com + Up to 3.5% Cash Back)

It is basically a 2 in 1 product which has one side pencil and second side tinted setting gel. First, pencil in brow color with short, light strokes following the natural direction of brow hair growth. Next, brush sheer-tint gel through brows and let set.

Source:walmart.com

It's easy to sharpen and there is less product wastage I have noticed so far. It provides natural finish to the brows and pigmentation is good and medium. The color is extremely subtle and natural and the pencil is thin enough that it's perfect for detail work or thinner brows. It comes in four shades.

If you like online shopping,don't forget to sign up at Extrabux！(What is Extrabux),then you can enjoy up to 30% cashback on your order from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus!

NYX's Micro Brow Pencil

($10 at NYX Professional Makeup + Up to 3.5% Cash Back)

The pencil is a very thin pencil meaning it is very precise that allows for drawing perfectly precise little hairs, and you can use the pencil to draw hair-like strokes in the areas of your brows that are sparse but you can also fill in your brows where they are much fuller and extend the "tail" end of your brows.

Source:NYX Professional Makeup

It's a micromechanical brow pencil, and it comes in eight shades - Taupe, Blonde, Auburn, Chocolate, Ash Brown, Brunette, Espresso, and Black. It doesn't feel over-the-top smooth which is actually a good thing.

Source:NYX Professional Makeup

Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Retractable

($4.29 at walgreens.com + Up to 6% Cash Back)

This sweat resistant formula can beautifully define your brows using its triangular pencil tip. It has a thin & slanted pencil tip that makes filling in my eyebrows quick & easy. The pencil is also retractable. It's waxy built-up ensures that the product stays put throughout the day with its excellent hold.

Source:walgreens

The Ultimate Brow pencil tip is soft but not ultra creamy. They look very natural. The color is perfect and the pigmentation is great. It's a very easy brow product to use and great for bold or soft everyday brows. You can take your pick amongst the four different shades of medium brown, ash brown, dark brown and taupe.

Source:walgreens

Maybelline EyeStudio Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil Makeup

($7.99 at Maybelline + Up to 6% Cash Back)

Brow Precise is an automatic self sharpening pencil that you twist to push the tip of the brow colour stick out. This Brow Precise pencil has a super fine 1.5mm micro tip on one end and a grooming brush on the other.

Source:Maybelline

The actual product is very creamy and certainly not as solid as pencils I have worked with before. It glides onto the brows effortlessly. And the pigmentation still showed up very well. However, this made it more difficult to work with. If you like smaller brow pencils, you can pick this up. There are four different color options of this pencil.

Source:Maybelline

Benefit Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil

( From $12 at sephora.com + Up to 4% Cash Back)

The Goof Proof Brow Pencil comes in a whimsical shiny silver dual-ended pencil with an ergonomic triangular barrel. It also has a spoolie brush that helps to blend the product and brush your eyebrows.

Source:sephora.com

The formula is quite easy to apply, not too stiff, not too dry and pigmented enough without overdoing it. It's easy to blend with the spoolie brush. It's not overly creamy or pigmented, which is good. Available in six shades, the Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil caters nicely to most hair colors.

Source:sephora.com

Milani Easy Brow Automatic Pencil

($4.49 at Milani Cosmetics + Up to 6% Cash Back)

The Easy Brow Automatic Pencil by Milani's can help in filling even the smallest of gaps to impart a natural-looking volume. The smooth-glide, water-resistant formula fills even the smallest gaps with natural-looking volume. A spoolie brush on the opposite end blends and grooms for professional results.

Source:Milani Cosmetics

The color is rich and easy to apply. It can create fine or bold lines. Spoolie brush works well to tame brows. There are currently two shades available - dark brown and natural taupe. One meant for blonde and light brown hair and a second meant for medium and dark brown hair.