It contains affiliate links and Extrabux will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on Extrabux links.


Vital Proteins vs. Ancient Nutrition vs. NeoCell vs. Bulletproof: Which Makes the NO.1 Collagen Brand?

Vital Proteins vs. Ancient Nutrition vs. NeoCell vs. Bulletproof: Which Makes the NO.1 Collagen Brand?

    Collagen is the main structural protein that forms our body's connective tissue—such as bone, skin, cartilage, and tendons. Research shows that collagen loss starts between the ages of 18 and 29, after age 40, the body can lose around 1% per year; at around age 80, collagen production can decrease 75% overall in comparison to that of young adults. Therefore, it is very important to supplement collagen. Consuming collagen peptides supplements may help with skin elasticity, stronger bones, pain-free joints, and a more secure gut lining. Common collagen brands on the market are Vital Proteins, Ancient Nutrition, NeoCell, and Bulletproof. But which one is the best? Here we've gathered the advantages & disadvantages, customer services, promotions, and best sellers of each of these brands to help you pick a winner.

1. Vital Proteins

Vital Proteins was then established in 2013 in Chicago, Illinois. It is a wellness brand that specializes in producing collagen supplements for health, beauty, and fitness. With a company focused on supplying customers sustainably sourced collagen in order to maintain a vibrant life as we age, Vital Proteins offers its products in various forms such as powders and drinks. 

Vital Proteins is the most trusted brand that people across the world have seen the best results from. The brand has gained notoriety over the years as famed actress and celebrity, Jennifer Aniston, became Vital Proteins’ Chief Creative Officer in 2020. With a following of over 666k on Instagram, Vital Proteins has also been featured on numerous media outlets such as PopSugar, Women’s Health, Refinery29, and People Magazine. 



  • There are zero fillers in their powder.

  • They use a third party to test for microbiological components and heavy metals.

  • Their containers are BPA free and they completely seal out moisture to prevent contamination.

  • Every product comes from authentic, natural food sources.

  • Their products are gluten free and Whole 30 approved.

Pros & Cons


Variety of collagen products made into different forms such as supplements, powders, and drinks.

Products are limited to those who are vegan. This is because collagen is sourced from grass-fed bovine.
Customers can shop through health need, such as collagen products for beauty, sleep, diet, fitness, or energy.

All ingredients have environmentally friendly sourcing.

Subscription plan allows customers to save 25% off with free shipping and free samples added.

Positive customer reviews.

Customer Service

If you have a question? You will feel free to contact Vital Proteins.

  • By Phone

Call Vital Proteins at (224) 544-9110 – Their business hours are 9:00AM and 5:00PM Central Time, Monday through Friday, except holidays.

  • By Email 

You can send Vital Proteins an e-mail with your questions or comments to At this time they are experiencing increased customer outreach related to COVID-19. Please allow their Customer Advocate team up to 48 business hours to respond back to your request. Their business hours are 9:00AM and 5:00PM Central Time, Monday through Friday, except holidays.

  • FAQ

Also, their FAQ is a helpful resource, if you're looking for a starting point.

  • Mail

Send questions, comments, and fan mail to:

3400 Wolf Rd

Franklin Park, IL 60131

Return Policy

They hope that you love their products, but they understand that sometimes things just don’t work out. They ask that you notify them of any problems within 30 days of the receipt of your order. They reserve the right to change or amend this policy. In some instances, certain returns may be subject to a restocking fee, but please reach out to them first so they can help you resolve any questions or issues you may have.

Please contact their Customer Advocate team at (224) 544-9110,, or their e-chat feature for assistance in returning the item. A Customer Advocate will answer your questions between 9:00AM and 5:00PM Central Time, Monday through Friday, except holidays.

Returns should be addressed to:

Vital Proteins

3400 Wolf Rd Ste 200,

Franklin Park, IL 60131

Best Sellers

1. Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides

Vital Proteins has a full line of collagen products, including flavored and unflavored powders, ready-to-drink beverages, gummies, bars, and creamers.The products contain collagen from either grass-fed bovine or wild-caught marine sources. 

The powder contains type I and type III hydrolyzed collagen sourced from grass-fed cattle, vitamin C, and hyaluronic acid.


2. Vital Proteins Marine Collagen

Vital Proteins Marine Collagen is made from the scales of fresh, non-GMO, wild-caught white fish off the coast of Alaska. It’s highly bioavailable, digestible and soluble in cold water. Beneficial: Helps promote youthful skin, healthier hair, stronger nails, joint health, and bone health. Bioavailable: Digested and absorbed by the body quickly for maximum benefits. Easy to Use: Soluble in hot or cold liquids, including coffee, smoothies, and baked goods. Adding a scoop of this marine collagen powder to different foods (like desserts or dressings) or beverages (like smoothies or water) gives you the boost you need to support healthy hair, skin, nails and joints.


3. Vital Proteins Beauty Collagen

Akin to those magical, age-defying potions that seem right out of a fairytale, the Beauty Collagen powder is designed to help promote a youthful appearance. Introducing a subtle blend of bovine hide collagen peptides, hyaluronic acid, and probiotics, this formula works on the inside to support hair, skin, and nails. 

With added organic ingredients of lemon, lavender, blueberry, and beet, this product uses the best of what nature has to offer in order to reduce the signs of aging.

There are no added sugars, fillers, or additives, so you know that you’re only ingesting what’s needed for your body. There are four flavors for the Beauty Collagen powder, such as lavender lemon, strawberry lemon, tropical hibiscus, and watermelon mint. 


Where to buy Vital Proteins?

You can gVital Proteins official website to buy collagen & proteins, and don't forget to sign up at Extrabux (What is Extrabux?) , then you can get 2.5% super cashback from Extrabux! Sign-Up Bonus: Free to join it & get $20 welcome bonus!


1. Sign up at Vital Proteins for 15% off your purchase;

2. Subscription plan allows customers to save 25% off with free shipping and free samples added

2. Bulletproof

Bulletproof products use only high-quality ingredients and the most precise formulas with active ingredients.

Bulletproof Collagen Protein is made of predominantly Type I and a small amount of Type III bovine collagen that comes from pasture-raised cows without added hormones. Bulletproof Collagen is enzymatically processed several times, to leave its nutrition-giving peptides intact. That makes it highly bioavailable for maximum impact.

According to the website, Bulletproof’s collagen formula is enzymatically processed several times. This means that it leaves its peptides intact instead of killing them off in harsh chemical processes. 

This process also allows the collagen to be very bioavailable, which means that you’re able to absorb it better than other brands. It comes in a powder form that is odorless, easy to use, and tastes great.


Pros & Cons


Mixes into hot and cold beverages easily.

Might be hard to get if you live outside the United States.

Comes from pasture-raised cows without the use of hormones.

All ingredients have environmentally friendly sourcing.

Unflavored so it can be used in a variety of recipes.

Contains 20+ grams of hydrolyzed collagen per serving.

Subscription plan allows customers to save 10% off with free shipping on orders over $35.

Provides 18 amino acids.

Helps stimulate the body to produce more collagen.

Vanilla and chocolate flavors available.

Customer Service

Have a question about Bulletproof Coffee or a recent order? They're here to help, available by phone, email, text or online chat!

Contact Customer Care:


Or submit a request online.

Return Policy

Except for Authorized Resellers, products may be returned within thirty (30) days of the date of purchase for a full refund, less shipping and handling.

They do require an RMA, please submit a request by clicking the 'customer support' link below to receive one.

If you send a return without an RMA, they're not going to know that it was sent back, and no action will be taken. Please be sure to get an RMA first before sending a return.

Returned items must be unopened. If you already opened the product and were not satisfied, please submit a request to Customer Care.

Please note: Bulletproof does not absorb the return shipping cost charged by your chosen carrier.

Best Sellers

1. Bulletproof Unflavored Collagen Protein

Bulletproof Collagen protein makes it easy to get the same vital amino acids found in bone broth without the time-consuming preparation. And because collagen is flavorless and blends in quickly without clumps, it’s one of the easiest ways to add a protein boost to smoothies, soups, and of course, Bulletproof Coffee.

  • Mixes easily in hot or cold drinks

  • Flavorless, so you can add it to anything from coffee to smoothies

  • Collagen protein from pasture-raised cows

  • Supports glowing and hydrated skin

  • Supports bone and joint health


2. Bulletproof Vanilla Collagen Protein

Bulletproof Vanilla Collagen Protein contains more collagen than most bone broth and can be consumed any time of the day. Enjoy a delicious vanilla flavor that contains only 1g of sugar while you take in all the health benefits of collagen peptides and coconut oil. Add it to Bulletproof coffee, smoothies, recipes and more for a daily protein boost.


Where to buy Bulletproof?

You can gBulletproof official website to buy collagens thruogh Extrabux, then you can get up to 3% super cashback.


1. Sign up at Bulletproof for 15% off your order;

2. Subscription plan allows customers to save 10% off with free shipping on orders over $35.

3. Ancient Nutrition

Ancient Protein is one of the best multi-collagen proteins to be found. The collagen supplement gets its all five types of collagens (including Type I, Type II, Type III, Type V, and Type X) from different sources that are – chicken, eggshell, bovine, and fish proteins. Thus making it a non-vegetarian product type. The product has been used for curing joint pain, gut problems, skin, nails, and hair problems. 

Even it is claimed that the effectiveness for the same can be seen within after the first day.  The miscibility of the product is quite good based on customer reviews. 


Best Seller

1. Dr. Axe / Ancient Nutrition, Multi Collagen Protein

Clinically proven to promote healthy skin, hair, joints & digestion. Ancient Nutrition transforms your health and vitality with history's healthiest whole food nutrients.

Their Multi Collagen Protein is uniquely formulated with 5 types of food source collagen that are clinically proven to promote healthy hair, skin, joints and digestion.

Clinically-studied source of Types V and X collagen to improve crow's feet after 4 weeks.

Clinically-studied source of Types V and X collagen to reduce joint discomfort in 7 days.

  • Clinically Studied Ingredients

  • Dr. Axe Formula

  • 5 Types of Food Source Collagen - Type I, II, III, V & X

  • Vitamin C + Probiotics

  • Collagen 20 g Per 2 Scoops

  • Grass-Fed Pasture Raised

  • Non GMO

  • Whole Food Dietary Supplement

  • Skin, Gut, Nails, Hair, Joints


Pros & Cons


Uses hydrolyzed bovine collagen.

Lacks key minerals.

Contains 5 different collagen types.

Doesn't specify amino acid profile.

Where to buy Ancient Nutrition?

You can gAncient Nutrition official website to buy collagens, currently no cashback availiable from Extrabux.

But you can also go iHerb to buy Dr. Axe / Ancient Nutrition, Multi Collagen Protein, then you can get up to 5%  Super Cash Back.

iHerb Promotions

1. Use Coupon "LOYALTY10", Get Free Shipping on Orders over $20 & Save 10% Instantly When You Spend $40;

2. Up to 15% Off Brands of the Week;

3. Join iHerb Rewards & Give Your Friends 10% Credit off Their First Order and You Also Get 10% Rewards.

4. NeoCell

NeoCell is the originator and industry authority on solutions that promote vital collagen health. As the pioneer in collagen science and supplementation, NeoCell has helped people worldwide live healthy and active lifestyles for over 17 years. NeoCell, America’s number #1 Collagen brand, is a family-owned, research-oriented company that manufactures premium, low molecular weight collagen-based products. Each NeoCell product is designed specifically to support the collagen systems in the body such as those that maintain vibrant youth, radiant beauty and total body wellness.

The NeoCell company was launched in 1998, basing its beauty and health products on science. NeoCell is a brand primarily focused on collagen. These products aren’t just a supplement for women. They can meet the health needs of men as well. 


Best Sellers

1. Neocell, Super Collagen + C, Collagen Type 1 & 3

Super Collagen +C is a NeoCell supplement formula with six grams of hydrolyzed peptides (types 1 and 3). It also has vitamin C for free radical protection. This supplement with vitamin C is ideal for supporting thicker hair and nails and providing cellular health on a deep level. 

According to NeoCell, in a study, after three months, 92% of participants taking Super Collagen +C said they had improved skin hydration. Sixty percent of participants said they had softer, firmer skin. 

  • True Science of Collagen 

  • Collagen Type 1 & 3 

  • Vitamin C 

  • For Healthy Skin, Hair, Nails & Joint Support 

  • 6 g Collagen 

  • Dietary Supplement 

  • Grass-Fed

  • Paleo-Friendly + Gluten-Free 

  • Igen - Non-GMO Tested 

  • Certified Paleo Friendly 


2. Neocell, Marine Collagen

Feed your bliss and nourish your inner beauty with our Marine Collagen. It contains two powerful ingredients: hyaluronic acid and collagen. Hyaluronic acid is a critical nutrient for tissue hydration, and collagen is responsible for your skin's structural integrity. When combined, they work synergistically to promote radiant healthy and strong skin from the inside out.

  • True Science of Collagen

  • Collagen Type 1 & 3

  • Hyaluronic Acid

  • For Radiant & Youthful Skin

  • 2 g Collagen

  • Dietary Supplement

  • Paleo-Friendly + Gluten Free

  • Igen Non-GMO Tested

  • Certified Paleo-Friendly


3. Neocell, Collagen Beauty Builder

Boost your inner beauty. Collagen Beauty Builder nourishes your body with healthy nutrients that support your radiant beauty from the inside out.

  • Collagen Type 1 & 3

  • Hyaluronic Acid

  • Biotin

  • For Radiant Skin, Healthy Hair & Nails

  • 3 g Collagen Per Serving

  • Dietary Supplement

  • Grass-Fed + Gluten-Free

  • Igen Non-GMO Tested

  • This Product is Keto Certified 


Where to buy Neocell?

You can gNneocell official website to buy collagens. And you can also go iHerb to buy Neocell collagens.


2021-09-25 01:305569